Lisa
Moderator
- Location
- Alberta, Canada
That's a shame.there seems to be such negativity about daring to be proud of your country that it’s getting hard to muster up the enthusiasm.
It’s the anniversary of confederation, which happened on July 1, 1897. Basically the birth of Canada as a country.That's a shame.
I was wondering, what does Canada Day actually celebrate ? Is it a particular historic event?
I suppose in the UK we have the Royal family which gives us cause for national festivities, although not popular with everyone.
I guess that makes it tricky, but surely they are the bedrock of Canada. Apologies I'm not up with the political landscape in Canada. Similar in Australia/New Zealand/US I guess.First Nations people
Yes the whole issue is very sensitive on many levels. It’s all very emotional for many people. I do think Canada is making progress in recognizing the issues that our First Nations people have but there is definitely more that could be done. How to fix it all is a debate that continues but I think we are getting better at listening to them rather than constantly making decisions for them.I guess that makes it tricky, but surely they are the bedrock of Canada. Apologies I'm not up with the political landscape in Canada. Similar in Australia/New Zealand/US I guess.
I don't think our own brand of Scottish Nationalism where we don't have that issue is covered in glory, but here too there is a culture of inclusiveness and that in many ways suppresses, or tries to suppress the nationalist pride, which unfortunately can be racist and not inclusive, just like everywhere else.
I'm sure I haven't quite expressed that right. I don't mean to offend anyone.

Yes it's the same here, Australia day celebrates the arrival of the First Fleet and it's always been a huge day of celebration with activities on the harbour and backyard barbies and a feeling of pride. It still is but now with much guilt and less celebration out of respect for our First PeopleYes the whole issue is very sensitive on many levels. It’s all very emotional for many people. I do think Canada is making progress in recognizing the issues that our First Nations people have but there is definitely more that could be done. How to fix it all is a debate that continues but I think we are getting better at listening to them rather than constantly making decisions for them.
I don’t want to offend either - I think most people feel the same way. It was interesting this year - one of our Alberta cities said they would ban the Canada Day fireworks out of sensitivity to the First Nations people and the ongoing issues they face and then an indigenous woman wrote an article saying basically, “hang on, did anyone consult with us before you made that decision?” (They hadn’t).
National pride can often get mixed up in racism and other negative attitudes, it can all be so depressing at times!!![]()